Reduce Excessive Motions

Intro1 Motions
Finding effective ways to reduce motions has been a hallmark of classic methods engineering a century ago and industrial ergonomics in more recent decades.

Production issues

The time needed for unnecessary motions in a highly cyclical job can add up to significant waste by the end of a day.  In any type of work, extensive sweeping motions can hinder production.

Employee well-being

The motions themselves can contribute to injury of the sensitive tissue sur­rounding the joints, especially in combination with awkward working position and excessive force.  This effect has attracted considerable attention in recent decades, as indicated by the term repetitive motion disorders. Understanding the relationship between production and well-being is exceptionally important.  In the author’s experience, a significant number of these disorders could have been prevented by following some of the most rudimentary concepts of methods engineering from a century ago.

Strategies for Improvement

Parts handling

Layout Double handling Slide Orient Prevent jumbling

Tools and equipment

Power tools and equipment Hoppers Quick releases Motion-saving mechanisms

Methods and process

Design for assembly Individual work method Reduce range of motions  

Measurements

Counting motions Posture evaluation

Strategies for improvement

Parts Handling

Improve layout

WastedSteps Sequential
Before After
One of the easiest and most common ways to reduce motions is to improve the layout of individual workstations and whole work areas. Changing the location of materials and sequence of tasks can eliminate many unnecessary hand and arm motions, along with lifting and walking. The example above shows changes to a work cell.  Motions are still required in the improved set-up, but there are fewer motions — especially fewer of the especially wasteful heavy motions needed to transfer items from one location to the next.  See Workstations: Layout.

Eliminate double-handling

Double1 Double2 Double3
Box of components brought into area, put on edge of tub Components transferred to different box on cart Cart moved to workstation
Double-handling is basically doing the same work twice — picking up and replacing an object only to have to pick it up and handle it again.  Improving layout can often eliminate the problem, but other factors can include the overall material handling system, the types of containers or totes used, andparts handling within the workstation. The example above is actually triple-handling. Ideally, the box of components should have been put on the cart at the preceding operation and simply wheeled to the point of use (or some equivalent).

Slide rather than pick up and put down

Recessed1 recessed2
Before: Pick up every time After: Slide
It is usually better to slide items rather than pick them up repetitively one at a time to place in their locations. Although motions are still required for sliding, the total number is usually reduced. The example above shows a small machine recessed into a work surface. The process is a very high volume assembly task and this simple change eliminated thousands of motions that added up to hundreds of hours per year.
Hole2 little conveyor
Hole in work surface Short length of conveyor
Cutting a hole in a workbenches permits sliding items into containers or conveyors, rather than needing to pick them up and then put them down. Adding an inexpensive short length of roller conveyor enables the assembler to slide the product to the next position. Arm motions are still required, but it takes fewer motions to slide the item than to pick it up and then put it down. In addition to Workstations: Parts handling; Material handling: SlidesConveyors.

Keep materials oriented

Example1bf sm Example2b
Before: Wrong orientation After: Correct orientation
A common problem is that materials are fed to a workstation in the wrong orientation. Consequently, the first step of the task is a wasted motion to correct the orientation. The machine in the example above requires a horizontal orientation for the cylinders. However, the cylinders were conveyed to the machine vertically, which required an needless motion to both at this machine and at the previous operation. In fact, the biggest benefit of this change was for the operator who loaded the cylinders on the conveyor, since it was much easier to load them horizontally. See Workstations: Parts handling.

Prevent jumbling

Jumble2b Jumble4
Jumbled Aligned
One of the most senseless repetitive tasks is to straighten out jumbled parts that had once been aligned. In the example above, these bars were cut from from a straight rod, but immediately dropped into a bin disorganized. The improvement was to configure guides that maintained the orientation of the bars as they fell, thus preventing them from being jumbled.
Tools and equipment

Power tools and equipment

Tool1 Tool2
Manual Powered
One of the obvious ways to reduce motions is to allow machines and tools to do the work. Machines are good at performing repetitive tasks endlessly, so they should be exploited.  
Press1 Press2
Before: Arm motion, one piece at a time After: Finger push, four pieces at a time
  One advantage of powered equipment is that typically, it is possible to work on more items at a single stroke than manually. The example above shows an arbor press that was replaced with a powered press. The arbor press was capable of completing only one item at a time. In contrast, the powered unit completed four at a time.

Hoppers

PowderScoop PowderHopper
Manual scoop Hopper
Hoppers save time and motions compared to using manual scoops. This example shows handling powder, but hoppers can be used for other materials, in particular small parts on assembly lines.

Quick releases

QuickRelease1 QuickRelease2
Screw clamp: Many motions Quick release: one motion
An excellent technique that can be used in many application is a quick release. For more examples see Quick releases; Maintenance: Access panels; Workstations: Bench-top fixturesFree-standing fixtures, Machine Operations: Covers and doors

Motion-saving mechanisms

There are a number of mechanical devices that can be applied to save motions. Many of these are age-old labor-saving devices that can be used today for low-cost solutions.
Gearing Ratchet3b
Gearing — one turn yields multiple turns Ratchet — eliminates repetitive grasping and regrasping
Yankee screwdriver remount Sewing machine2 pedal Sewing machine pedal
Yankee screwdriver— one push yields multiple turns Old-fashion sewing machine pedal — one stroke yields multiple reciprocal motions
RackPinion
Rack and pinion — one motion yields multiple turns
Methods and process

Design for assembly

DFA0 DFA2
Four insertions One insertion
One of the best approaches for eliminating motions is Design for Assembly. There are multitudes of techniques that have been developed in this improvement process that eliminate steps. The example above shows an electronics component that required four leads to be inserted by hand. With redesign, the leads were connected in a single component in an automated operation off line, then that single component was added, which required only a single insertion.

Improve work method

Technique
Boning chucks — Technique is critical
It is not uncommon to see two people working side by side on the same task, one working smoothly and the other with hectic, exaggerated, and wasted motions. In the above example, experienced meat cutters used only 50% of the effort compared to inexperienced workers. It is important to help employees learn to use the most efficient, least injurious methods. The video camera offers an excellent tool to help find the best method — you can videotape various individuals, then watch the tapes during group meetings to identify good techniques.

Reduce the range of the motion

Range1 Range2
Sweeping motion Small motion
There is a distinction between a small, simple motion and a large sweeping one. Thus, even if a motion cannot be eliminated altogether, it might be changed to a better one and thus still save time and strain on joints. In the packing example above left, placing the shipping box on the same surface as the items to be boxed creates an awkward up and down motion.  In contrast, the packing station above right has a lower stand for the shipping box, set so the top of the box is level with the items to be packed.  Thus, all that is necessary is a simple movement laterally. See Workstations:Packing Improvements of this type can be achieved by addressing heights and reaches with particular attention to layoutparts handlingpoint-of-use storage, and machine controls.

Measurements

Motions can by quantified by counting. Also, posture evaluation can be helpful in minimizing the extent of an individual motion.